You read one thing on a US site, a friend in Germany tells you another, and your pediatrician says a third. It is easy to conclude that someone is wrong. Sometimes one piece of advice really is out of date. More often nobody is wrong, and each of them is answering a slightly different question.

At a glance: five rules, five sources

TopicUS (AAP)UK (NHS)GermanyCroatiaWHO
Baby sleeps in parents' roomat least 6 monthsat least 6 monthsthe first yearat least to 6 months (HZJZ)–
Starting solidsaround 6 monthsaround 6 monthsafter 4 full months, by the start of month 7 at the latest–at 6 months
Vitamin D–8.5–10 µg (340–400 IU) to age 1 (not with more than 500 ml formula a day), then 10 µg (400 IU) to age 4400–500 IU until the second early summer; fluoride is a separate decision400 IU through the first year, then 600–800 IU October–April (summary of an expert paper, 2026, not a national protocol)–
Flu vaccine for healthy childreneveryone from 6 months, every yearages 2–3 and school-age children, nasal spraychildren with underlying conditions, not healthy children in general––
Oil for cradle cap–not olive oilbaby oil or olive oil––

1 µg of vitamin D is 40 IU. A dash means we did not find a current source we could open and check ourselves, or that the organization does not give a number for that topic. It does not mean something is forbidden. For Croatian advice on solids and flu vaccines we would rather leave a blank than guess. Details and sources are below.

Advertisement

How a recommendation is made

A recommendation for parents is not the same thing as a research finding. Research might show that a risk is highest in the first six months and falls toward the first birthday. Someone then has to decide where to draw the line: at six months, at a year, or nowhere, with an "it depends."

That decision is made by expert bodies: the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), the UK's NHS, Germany's federal public health institute (BIÖG) and its standing vaccine committee (STIKO, based at the Robert Koch Institute), Croatia's public health institute (HZJZ), the World Health Organization (WHO). Each writes for its own parents, its own system and its own climate. When two numbers differ, the reason can be the quality of the evidence, the year the advice was written, local risks, or how a committee weighed the data. Usually it is a mix.

Five examples show this well.

1. Room-sharing: six months or a year

The AAP advises that a baby sleep in the parents' room, in their own crib, for at least the first six months (AAP, HealthyChildren.org). The NHS says the same: a separate cot in the same room, for every sleep, for at least the first six months (NHS). Croatia's public health institute uses almost the same words in its leaflet for parents: keep the cot in the parents' room at least until 6 months of age (HZJZ, Sigurno kroz prvu godinu).

Germany's BIÖG goes further. The cot should stand in the parents' bedroom for the whole first year, on the reasoning that the parents' steady breathing has a positive effect on the baby's breathing regulation (BIÖG, Vorbeugung Kindstod).

Nobody here contradicts anybody. They all agree the risk of sudden infant death is highest in the first six months, and the NHS adds that it can happen up to 12 months. The only difference is where the line sits. If your baby is still in your room at seven months, you are not breaking anyone's rule.

2. Solids: five months or six

This is the one that confuses parents most. The WHO recommends exclusive breastfeeding for the first six months and solids from six months (WHO). The NHS says "around 6 months" (NHS), and the AAP recommends only breast milk for "approximately 6 months" (AAP).

Germany gives a window instead of a single number: solids no earlier than after the fourth full month, and no later than the start of the seventh (BIÖG, Beikosteinführung). According to BIÖG, German families usually start between the fifth and seventh month, with a purée of vegetables, potato and meat.

Why the gap? The WHO's six months is not just a simple number for the world; it is tied to its recommendation of exclusive breastfeeding up to that point. Germany's window is a genuinely different recommendation, because it allows starting earlier, from the fifth month. The sources do not spell out why; our reading is that German guidance leaves room for the pediatrician and parent to decide by the child, within limits. Both ask for the same things: a baby showing signs of readiness, and no solids before four months. Our guide to signs your baby is ready for solids covers what those signs look like.

3. Vitamin D: how long depends on the sun

The NHS says babies up to age one need 8.5 to 10 micrograms of vitamin D a day, except babies drinking more than 500 ml of formula a day, because formula is already fortified. Children aged 1 to 4 then get 10 micrograms a day, all year round (NHS, Vitamins for children). For everyone else, the NHS notes that from late March to the end of September most people can make enough vitamin D from sunlight (NHS, Vitamin D).

Germany's Gesund ins Leben network recommends 400 to 500 IU a day until the child has lived through a second early summer, so 12 to 18 months depending on birth date. The reason is stated right next to the advice: until stronger vitamin D production from sunlight kicks in (Gesund ins Leben). Until the first tooth it comes in one tablet with fluoride, for the teeth, and after that parents choose between several options.

And Croatia? A guideline review published in Paediatria Croatica in October 2026 recommends 400 IU a day through the whole first year, then 600–800 IU a day for children aged 1 to 13 from October to April, or all year if there are ongoing risk factors (Vranesic Bender, Paediatria Croatica 2026;70(suppl 4):58). It is an expert paper that brings together international consensus statements and Croatia's 2016 national guidelines, not a separate HZJZ recommendation. Like the German advice, it ties vitamin D for older children to the season, not just to age.

So the difference has two layers. One is geography: a baby born in November faces a winter with little sun, and the German advice handles that through a date rather than an age. The other is organizational: the UK separates breastfed and formula-fed babies and runs longer, to age four, while in Germany vitamin D often comes in one tablet with fluoride. How long vitamin D runs and how teeth are protected are still two separate decisions.

4. Flu: one virus, three strategies

The AAP recommends a flu vaccine for everyone six months and older, every year (AAP, Flu).

The NHS vaccinates children aged two and three and school-age children, mostly with a nasal spray, plus children with long-term conditions from six months. The vaccine protects the child, since each winter thousands of UK children without a health condition need hospital care for flu, and it also helps protect others: children spread flu to babies, pregnant women and older people (NHS, Children's flu vaccine).

Germany's STIKO recommends it in childhood for children with underlying conditions, but not for healthy children in general, according to the RKI's FAQ (as of 2024). The Robert Koch Institute says STIKO has made this a priority topic and is reviewing an extension (RKI, Influenza-Impfung).

The programs differ in who is covered and how the vaccine is given. Protecting the child and slowing spread can be goals at the same time, not one or the other. For your child, your country's current recommendation and your pediatrician's view of their circumstances are what count. Decisions like these also depend on who gives the vaccine, what it costs the system and how many people are already vaccinated. That is why flu advice changes more often than most. If your child is sick right now, cold or flu in a baby walks through the difference.

5. Cradle cap: when evidence is thin, opinions split

For cradle cap, the greasy scales on a baby's scalp, most advice agrees: soften, brush gently, don't pick. The difference is one detail. German pediatricians (BVKJ) mention baby oil or olive oil (Kinderärzte im Netz). The NHS says plainly not to use olive oil, as it may not be good for the skin (NHS, Cradle cap).

The reason is a little uncomfortable: the research on treating cradle cap is thin and weak, which is not the same as no research at all. A 2019 Cochrane review rated the evidence for every treatment it looked at as very low certainty (Cochrane). When the evidence is missing, advice leans on experience and caution, and caution looks different in different countries. Both pages are general advice for parents, the German one a pediatricians' news piece, so neither has to be the single current position of a whole country. If you want to use an oil or cream, ask your pediatrician or pharmacist which product suits your baby's skin. More in our cradle cap guide.

What this means for you

Parents now read advice from everywhere, so these differences come up more than they used to. A few rules help:

If you want the individual topics, we have separate guides on baby-led weaning vs purées and fever after vaccination.

For how to turn your questions into a useful visit, see our guide to preparing for a pediatric visit.

How we handle these differences

KidyGrow publishes in English, Croatian, Spanish and German. We don't translate the German articles from English; we write them from German sources: BIÖG, German pediatricians, the RKI and STIKO. When German advice differs from US or UK advice, the article says both and explains the gap instead of quietly picking one. This comparison grew out of that work.

Frequently asked questions

So which advice is right?
Usually both, for their own system. For your child, what counts is your pediatrician's advice and your national guidance. Foreign advice is useful background for that conversation.

Why does Germany recommend the parents' room for the whole first year?
Germany's BIÖG says the parents' steady breathing helps the baby's breathing regulation. The AAP, NHS and Croatia's HZJZ set the line at at least six months. None of them says the other number is dangerous.

Can I start solids at five months?
Under German guidance that falls within the window, after four full months. The WHO, AAP and NHS talk about six months. Signs of readiness matter most, and it is a good question for your next well-child visit.

Why do vaccine recommendations differ more than others?
Because they also depend on what the vaccine costs, who gives it, how many people are vaccinated and whom the system most wants to protect. That is also why they change more often.

Do US babies need the German vitamin D and fluoride combination?
That is Germany's approach to preventing tooth decay. Ask your pediatrician what your child needs for vitamin D and for their teeth.

What if two sources say the exact opposite?
Check whether they are even from the same country and the same year. If they are and still disagree, it usually means the evidence is not solid, as with oil for cradle cap. That is the time to ask your pediatrician.

How KidyGrow helps you

Reading advice from three countries, it is easy to lose track of what your own pediatrician said.

In KidyGrow you can save your pediatrician and other specialists, plus your appointments with them. The app also remembers what you tell it, for example that your pediatrician said vitamin D until the first birthday or that you are starting solids at five months, and keeps that in mind next time you ask. With Pro, it prepares a short summary and suggested questions before an appointment.

It does not decide which advice is right. It helps you walk into the appointment with a question instead of five open tabs.

_Editorial note: this comparison was researched and written by Marija, founder of KidyGrow and a mum. Every source was opened and checked on 14 October 2026, and only recommendations we could read in the original were compared. This article has not been reviewed by a doctor and is not a substitute for your pediatrician's advice._

Sources

  1. American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org. "A Parent's Guide to Safe Sleep." https://www.healthychildren.org/English/ages-stages/baby/sleep/Pages/a-parents-guide-to-safe-sleep.aspx
  2. NHS. "Reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS)." https://www.nhs.uk/baby/caring-for-a-newborn/reduce-the-risk-of-sudden-infant-death-syndrome/
  3. Croatian Institute of Public Health (HZJZ). "Sigurno kroz prvu godinu" (leaflet for parents, 2023). https://www.hzjz.hr/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/Sigurno-kroz-prvu-godinu.pdf
  4. Bundesinstitut für Öffentliche Gesundheit (BIÖG), kindergesundheit-info.de. "Vorbeugung gegen den Plötzlichen Kindstod." https://www.kindergesundheit-info.de/themen/risiken-vorbeugen/ploetzlicher-kindstod-sids/vorbeugung-kindstod/
  5. World Health Organization. "Infant and young child feeding." https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/infant-and-young-child-feeding
  6. NHS. "Your baby's first solid foods." https://www.nhs.uk/baby/weaning-and-feeding/babys-first-solid-foods/
  7. American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org. "Starting Solid Foods." https://www.healthychildren.org/English/ages-stages/baby/feeding-nutrition/Pages/Starting-Solid-Foods.aspx
  8. BIÖG, kindergesundheit-info.de. "Beikosteinführung." https://www.kindergesundheit-info.de/themen/ernaehrung/0-12-monate/beikosteinfuehrung/
  9. NHS. "Vitamins for children." https://www.nhs.uk/baby/weaning-and-feeding/vitamins-for-children/
  10. NHS. "Vitamin D." https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/vitamins-and-minerals/vitamin-d/
  11. Netzwerk Gesund ins Leben. "Nährstoffsupplemente im 1. Lebensjahr." https://www.gesund-ins-leben.de/fuer-fachkreise/bestens-unterstuetzt-durchs-1-lebensjahr/handlungsempfehlungen/beikost/naehrstoffsupplemente-im-1-lebensjahr/
  12. Vranesic Bender D. "Overview of guidelines for the screening, prevention, and treatment of vitamin D deficiency in pediatrics: in health and disease." Paediatria Croatica, 2026;70(suppl 4):58. DOI: 10.13112/pc.1402
  13. American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org. "Flu." https://www.healthychildren.org/English/health-issues/conditions/flu/Pages/default.aspx
  14. NHS. "Children's flu vaccine." https://www.nhs.uk/vaccinations/child-flu-vaccine/
  15. Robert Koch-Institut. "Influenza-Impfung: Indikationsgruppen (FAQ)." https://www.rki.de/SharedDocs/FAQs/DE/Impfen/Influenza/FAQ_Liste_Indikationsgruppen.html
  16. Berufsverband der Kinder- und Jugendärzte, Kinderärzte im Netz. "Kopfgneis verschwindet meist von selbst." https://www.kinderaerzte-im-netz.de/news-archiv/meldung/kopfgneis-verschwindet-meist-von-selbst/
  17. NHS. "Cradle cap." https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/cradle-cap/
  18. Cochrane. "Treatments for infantile seborrhoeic dermatitis (including cradle cap)." 2019. https://www.cochrane.org/evidence/CD011380_treatments-infantile-seborrhoeic-dermatitis-including-cradle-cap-inflammatory-scaly-skin-condition