Moving from bottle to cup is less about the cup and more about the bottle's other jobs. By the first birthday a bottle is rarely just a drink. It is the thing that fills the gap before a nap, the thing that makes bedtime work, the thing a tired toddler asks for by pointing at the cupboard. The plan below takes those jobs away one at a time instead of all at once, and it says what to do when it goes sideways.

Quick Reference

AgeWhat to doDrinks and amounts
~6 monthsOffer an open or free-flow cup with mealsSips of water; 4–8 oz (120–240 ml) a day by 12 months
9–12 monthsCup at every meal; start replacing a daytime bottleBreast milk or formula still the main milk
12 monthsWhole cow's milk from a cup, not a bottleAbout 16 oz (480 ml) of milk a day
12–18 monthsDrop remaining bottles, bedtime lastWater between meals
~2 yearsMostly drinking from an open cupMilk 16–24 oz (480–720 ml) a day

When should you start the cup?

Around 6 months, when solids begin. The American Academy of Pediatrics says to start offering a cup "as early as 6 months" and to complete the transition "sometime between 12 and 18 months" (AAP, 2023). The NHS gives the same starting point, sips of water from a cup with meals from around 6 months, and is firmer about the end: "Once your baby is 1 year old, feeding from a bottle should be discouraged" (NHS).

Starting early is not about getting milk into the cup at six months. It is about practice. A baby who has had a cup at the table for six months already knows the cup is normal by the time you need it to replace something.

Six months of mostly wet bibs is still progress.

Advertisement

Why the bottle should go by 18 months

Two reasons get quoted, and one more that surprises most parents.

The first is teeth. AAP describes early childhood caries as what happens when teeth are "constantly bathed in milk, formula, juice or other drinks". A bottle sipped through a nap or carried around all morning does exactly that.

The second is appetite. AAP puts it bluntly: "Little ones who sip on bottles during the day often don't feel hungry at mealtimes." Milk goes down fast and fills a small stomach. That is a separate problem with its own fixes; here it is one more reason to move the milk into a cup and onto the meal table.

The third is weight. In a US cohort of 6,750 children, 22.3% were still using a bottle at 24 months. At five and a half, 22.9% of those children had obesity, against 16.1% of children who had stopped, and the link held after the researchers adjusted for income, maternal weight, breastfeeding, screen time and birth weight (Gooze et al., 2011). It is an observational study, so it shows a link and not a cause. Still, it is the clearest number for why "she just likes her bottle" at two and a half is worth gently changing.

Which cup to choose

The best cup is the one that teaches sipping, not sucking.

AAP's longer goal is an open cup by about 2 years. Pick one cup you like and buy two of it. The day one is in the dishwasher is the day nobody needs a negotiation.

A step-by-step plan that works for most families

This gradual plan is meant mainly for children past their first birthday. Before that, the cup is for practice: breast milk or formula stays the main milk drink and is not swapped for water.

  1. Weeks before: cup at every meal, no pressure. AAP suggests starting with whatever your child already drinks, breast milk or formula, because a familiar taste in a new container is an easier sell than water. Let your child see you drink from the same kind of cup.
  2. Drop the midday bottle first. It is usually the least emotional one. Serve milk in a cup at lunch instead.
  3. Wait 3–7 days, until the new version feels ordinary, then drop the morning bottle. Put breakfast milk in a cup at the table, not on the sofa.
  4. After 12 months, fill any remaining bottles with water between meals. This is an AAP suggestion and it works because water in a bottle is boring. The habit fades when the reward does.
  5. Bedtime last. See the next section.
  6. Put the bottles away out of sight once the last one is gone. A toddler who sees them in the drying rack will ask.

You can spread this over a few weeks and set the pace by your child. Some take longer, and that is fine as long as the direction stays the same.

Some families prefer one clean break: all bottles gone on a chosen day, sometimes with a small ritual such as giving them "to the new babies". It can work for a stubborn toddler who would fight each step separately. AAP recommends the gradual route, and for most children it means fewer tears in total, spread over more days.

How to handle the bedtime bottle

The bedtime bottle is usually the last one standing because it is doing a second job: it is how your child falls asleep. AAP warns that giving in and offering a bottle at bedtime can turn temporary sleep problems into "serious struggles", and suggests trusting your child to settle without it. A pacifier, a cuddle and a story can take over some of the bottle's job.

What helps is moving the milk, not removing it overnight.

If your child has been falling asleep sucking, the first few nights will be harder. That is a sleep association changing, not a feeding problem, and the same gentle steps that help a baby who only sleeps when held apply here too.

What if your child refuses milk from a cup?

Very common, and usually temporary. Many toddlers drink less milk for a week or two after the switch. If they eat well, that is not a problem. CDC counts yogurt and cheese toward the roughly two daily servings of dairy a child aged 12 to 23 months needs, and whole cow's milk can start at 12 months (CDC).

Try a different cup, a straw, milk at a slightly different temperature, or milk served alongside food rather than as its own event. If your child is over one, healthy, and eating, drinking and growing well, do not put the bottle back to "make sure they drink". For that child, two days of less milk will not hurt. If they are younger, unwell or drinking very little overall, check with your pediatrician. If you are unsure how much they should be drinking and eating overall, this toddler portion guide has the numbers.

If your child is younger and suddenly refuses the bottle itself, that is a different situation, covered in baby suddenly refuses the bottle.

Common setbacks and what to do

Not every regression has a reason you can find. Some weeks a toddler just wants the old thing back.

Common mistakes

When to talk to your pediatrician or dentist

For how milk, solids and meals fit together across the whole first three years, see the baby and toddler feeding guide.

Frequently asked questions

At what age should a baby stop using a bottle?
AAP recommends completing the switch between 12 and 18 months, and the NHS discourages bottle feeding from the first birthday. Starting the cup at 6 months makes that window much easier to hit.

Should I drop the bedtime bottle first or last?
Last, in most cases. It carries the most comfort and is often tied to falling asleep. Drop the midday and morning bottles first, then move bedtime milk to a cup earlier in the routine and brush teeth after it.

Is a sippy cup better than an open cup?
Not for the long term. A valved sippy cup still needs sucking, so it works like a bottle. Free-flow and straw cups are good stepping stones; an open cup by about 2 years is the goal.

My toddler drinks much less milk since we stopped the bottle. Is that a problem?
Usually not, if they are eating well. Yogurt and cheese count toward daily dairy, and around 16 oz (480 ml) of milk a day is plenty between 12 and 24 months. Talk to your pediatrician if weight gain slows.

Can I put water in the bottle to help the transition?
After the first birthday, yes, between meals. AAP suggests it, and it works because a bottle of plain water is far less interesting than a bottle of milk. Before 12 months, breast milk or formula stays the main drink, so do not replace milk feeds with water. Do not leave a bottle of milk in the cot.

What if my toddler screams for the bottle?
Hold the step you are on for a few more days rather than going back. Offer comfort in another form, a cuddle, a book, the same song. Most protest fades within a week when the answer stays the same.

How KidyGrow helps you

Week three of dropping bottles, you can no longer remember whether the morning bottle went on Tuesday or the Tuesday before. Add each bottle in KidyGrow in a few taps, and over a week you can see how many are still left. Tell Grow that the midday bottle is gone and bedtime is next, and the app remembers that the next time you ask about evenings. It will not decide which bottle to drop. That call stays yours. What changes is that you stop reconstructing last week from memory at 7pm.

Sources

  1. American Academy of Pediatrics. Discontinuing the Bottle. HealthyChildren.org, updated 2023.
  2. American Academy of Pediatrics. Recommended Drinks for Children Age 5 & Younger. HealthyChildren.org, updated 2023.
  3. NHS. Drinks and cups for babies and young children.
  4. NHS. Taking care of children's teeth.
  5. CDC. Cow's Milk and Milk Alternatives.
  6. Gooze RA, Anderson SE, Whitaker RC. Prolonged bottle use and obesity at 5.5 years of age in US children. J Pediatr. 2011;159(3):431–436.